22.11.2026 13:02
In the case of cousins who disappeared a day apart in January 2023 in the Kovancılar district of Elazığ, the Court of Cassation ruled that the inability to find the body did not prevent the filing of a case and overturned the decision to return the indictment. At the first hearing at the Elazığ 1st Heavy Penal Court, the defendants did not accept the charges. The detained defendant, shepherd M.D., claimed that he heard statements that Mustafa Yılmaz was taken away with his hands handcuffed and his eyes blindfolded, that he was asked for a pickaxe and shovel, and that lime was brought.
In Elazığ, in the case of the missing cousins that occurred about 4 years ago, the Court of Cassation issued a remarkable decision regarding the indictment that had been returned on the grounds that the body could not be found. The Court of Cassation ruled that the inability to find the body does not prevent the filing of a case, overturned the decision on the return of the indictment, and paved the way for the case. At the first hearing held, the detail of the pickaxe, shovel, axe and lime in the shepherd’s statement drew attention.
According to the information obtained, after 26-year-old Mustafa Yılmaz, living in the Kovancılar district of Elazığ, abducted 21-year-old N. N. Y., the two got married. After the incident, tensions began to occur between the Yılmaz family and the other side. Then Mustafa Yılmaz disappeared on January 22, 2023. Following Mustafa Yılmaz’s disappearance, his cousin O. Y. also disappeared one day later. Then, in an operation organized on February 2, 2023, 5 suspects were arrested, but since there was no body, no case could be filed and those in prison were released. Finally, after the restricted base report last year, the button was pressed again and 12 suspects were detained in an operation organized by the gendarmerie. While 3 suspects were released under judicial control conditions, M. Y., İ. Y., O. Y., F. Y. and M. D. were arrested again and sent to prison.
COURT OF CASSATION OVERTURNED THE RETURN DECISION, DEFENDANTS BEFORE A JUDGE FOR THE FIRST TIME
The file was taken to the Court of Cassation for the filing of the case and the trial to be held. As a result of the examination, the Court of Cassation ruled that the inability to find the body does not constitute an obstacle to filing a case, and that if there is sufficient evidence creating suspicion, the indictment should be accepted. It found the decision to return the indictment unlawful and overturned it. Within this scope, the first hearing was held at the 1st High Criminal Court of the Elazığ Courthouse, and the defendants appeared before a judge for the first time.
While the defendants did not accept the crimes attributed to them, remarkable statements came from the arrested M. D., who worked as a shepherd in the region. M. D. said: “While my horse and donkey were drinking water, I noticed a vehicle arriving; it honked twice. O. Y. had come in F. A.’s vehicle; later I learned whose vehicle it was. Then, when I went up, D. Y. and O. Y. were standing side by side; D. Y. had a small black pistol in his hand. I greeted them, we asked about each other’s health, and afterward, since I saw a gun in D. Y.’s hand, I asked. I said to D. Y., ‘Did you come for rabbits? You don’t hunt rabbits with a pistol either; why did you take the gun in your hand, is there a problem?’ and he told me there was no problem, they had come to take a walk. Before 3-5 minutes passed, when I looked inside the car, I noticed a person sitting in the front right passenger seat. I asked both of them, ‘Who is this friend, why isn’t he getting out of the car?’ and he said, ‘It’s none of your business, forget it, he’s just sitting there by himself.’ I said to them, ‘What are you doing? I’m going to Kovancılar,’ and they said, ‘Wait for us a bit, Ş. Y. will come, and then we’ll go to Kovancılar.’ After about half an hour or forty minutes passed, in the dialogues D. and O. established between themselves, they said, ‘We brought this boy’; the boy they meant was Mustafa. They talked among themselves about how D. Y. came to them and what happened on the road. They said that D. Y. drove his car rapidly toward O. Y., cut off the car as if O. Y. had no news of it, that his father M. Y. was beside him, that he took out his gun and held it out to Mustafa, and that O. Y. said, ‘Uncle, stop, don’t do it, don’t do it, the car will be covered in blood, then we’ll get into trouble.’ Then they came toward my village. After talking about these things, I noticed a car coming; the one coming by car was Ş. Y. O. Y. was with him; they got out of the car,” he said.
Continuing his statement, M. D. said: “As soon as Ş. Y. got out, when he said ‘Where is he?’, D. Y. extended his gun toward the car and said, ‘He’s sitting there in the car.’ Ş. Y. asked, ‘Didn’t you tie his hands?’ D. said, ‘No, we didn’t tie them.’ Ş. Y. said, ‘What if he runs away?’ Thereupon O. Y. intervened and said, ‘We smoked drugs together, he’s high, he won’t go anywhere, he won’t leave our side.’ Upon this, Ş. Y. headed toward the vehicle where Mustafa was, took Mustafa out of the vehicle and moved him 3-4 meters away from the vehicle. He said, ‘Is it worth it for 250 grams?’ When I heard this sentence, I had heard about the incident before, but until that moment I did not know who had abducted N. N., and I understood the incident. Ş. Y. punched Mustafa once or twice, and I said, ‘Stop, stop,’ to separate them; he said, ‘Don’t interfere.’ Ş. Y. said, ‘I won’t interfere.’ He took Mustafa to the side of the car again. Ş. Y. said to D. Y., ‘D., isn’t there something? Let’s tie this one’s hands.’ D. Y. took out the white plastic zip-tie handcuff from his pocket, and after taking it out, he tied Mustafa Yılmaz’s hands behind his back in a reverse handcuff, and seated him in the back seat of the car,” he said.
SHEPHERD ASKED FOR PICKAXE AND SHOVEL
M. D. continued his statement: “Meanwhile, Ş. Y. came over to O. Y. He said, ‘O., take the phones.’ He had both his own phone and Mustafa’s phone in his hand. After he said toward the direction of Kovancılar, ‘You go, take the phones to Elazığ Center too,’ O. Y. got into F. A.’s Tempra brand vehicle, and after getting in, O. Y. moved toward the direction of Kovancılar. After he moved, Ş. Y. asked me for my phone, and I said, ‘I don’t have a phone.’ He insistently said, ‘Give it to me, I’m going to call O. Y.’ I again said, ‘I won’t give it,’ but he insisted and put his hand toward the pocket of my shirt; my phone was already in my shirt pocket. He looked at the phone; when there was no signal, he moved 5-7 meters away from us and tried to find a signal. In the meantime, I did not see whether he called O. Y. or not. Then he came back down again, and he and D. Y. began speaking German among themselves. Meanwhile, O. Y. was sitting in the vehicle next to Mustafa Yılmaz. After Ş. Y. spoke with D. in German for a while, Ş. Y. said to me, ‘Do you have a pickaxe and shovel?’ Since they had abducted and brought Mustafa Yılmaz, punched him a few times and harmed him, I said to them, ‘I don’t have a pickaxe or shovel.’ Ş. Y. said to me, ‘You have a pickaxe and shovel; you raise that many animals, how could you not? The other day we came to your barn with you, 10 people worked,’ and I again said, ‘I don’t have a pickaxe or shovel.’
Speaking of the axe detail, M. D. said: “Then I began to go down toward below my house. He saw the axe I kept for chopping wood, part of which was for cutting wood and part of which could serve for digging. Ş. Y. took that axe, which also had a digging feature, and came; I held his hand and said, ‘Leave my pickaxe, that is, my axe.’ He said, ‘It’s just an axe, why are you chasing after it?’ and again asked me for a shovel. I told him I didn’t have one. Ş. Y. walked around the house once or twice but could not find the shovel. Ş. Y. had seen my fruit and vegetable garden before and said, ‘There is one there.’ He said, ‘You will come with me too.’ I said I would not come. Since Ş. Y. had come and gone to me before, he knew that the dogs I keep to protect my animals attack people; for this reason he had said, ‘You will come with me.’ I also went down to the stream with him so that I could check on the goat left behind.After going down to the stream, Ş. Y. went to the apple orchard; he had taken the shovel. Then he came to me, and after looking at the lost animal, while we were crossing over the stream, my phone rang; an unknown number was calling, I answered, it was a man’s voice, I did not know him. In Kurdish he said to me, ‘I have eaten, I am not coming; my brother has not eaten, I will send my brother to eat.’ The evening one day before this, 5-6 friends from different villages had come to dinner; after eating, we injected and vaccinated my animals; meanwhile, upon hearing this, Ş. Y. said, ‘Heh heh, okay’; Ş. Y. had also heard the conversation. I wondered who this was. Ş. Y. took the phone from me. He called again, they spoke a word or two. We came to the front of our door; he left the shovel and the axe over by the wall of the door, then we noticed that a car had come,’ he stated.
M. D. said, ‘Meanwhile I noticed the headlights of a car, I went out in front of the door. The vehicle turned back, and 10-15 minutes later Ş. Y. came on foot, “Where are you, where is D.?” he said; D. had also gone outside, “We are here,” he said. Ş. Y. asked D., “Where is Mustafa?” and D. said, “Inside.” Ş. Y. went and checked on Mustafa, he began shouting, “Why did you untie this man’s hands?” and D. said, “Nothing will happen, we are here.” Then Ş. Y. went outside, took the pickaxe (axe) and the shovel he had leaned against the wall and put them in his own green Eagle-brand vehicle; at the very end, while they were blindfolding Mustafa and taking him away, I saw that he had put these materials in the front seat,’ he said.
LIME DETAIL IN THE SHEPHERD’S STATEMENT
M. D. said, ‘In this regard I also want to state the following: just before going down to the stream, Ş. Y. said, “I have brought lime; I will give him what he deserves; I will take him to Kargan and shoot him.” During the investigation, Karsan and Kargan were confused; the correct one is Kargan. Afterwards, at the very end, while they were going to take Mustafa, they said to me, “You come too, get in the car,” and when I asked, “Where to, why am I coming?” Ş. Y. said to me, “Come, we have work to do,” and I said, “I will not come”; they said, “Why won’t you come?” and I said, “You have kidnapped and brought this boy here; I had told my wife that Ş. Y. was coming; if I come with you too, my wife will call the gendarmerie.” He then got angry at me, saying, “Why are you telling things to women?” Then he turned around, pointed at Mustafa, and said to me, “How are your kids and family, how are your children, are they doing well?” and said, “May they not become like this one,” that is, he threatened me. Because he had kidnapped Mustafa and tied his hands and eyes, I was going to inform the law enforcement; after he made this threat, I could not file a complaint out of fear,’ he said.
Also recounting an incident he had experienced about 15-20 days before the event, M. D. said, ‘Ş. Y. had previously asked me for cola and eggs, and when I was in Kovancılar, since it was on the way, when I dropped them off at my house, after some time passed, because he said, “Come, let’s have a meal, let’s drink tea,” I went to their house; I said, “Let me wash my hands”; M. Y., O. Y., and N. Y. were sitting, they were eating; I heard them say, “If we put lime in the barns and leave it for a week, they won’t be able to find anything,” but I may also have misunderstood. Since Ş. Y. also used the lime talk on the night of the event, I gave this statement as an additional statement to the prosecutor’s office. These are what I witnessed as a witness, not as a defendant. I have no involvement or complicity in the event; I request my acquittal and release from the crimes attributed to me,’ he said.
After the other defendants, witnesses and complainants were heard, the court adjourned the hearing to a later date.
.