Court of Cassation upholds conviction of woman who fed stray animals! Lawyer: Could set precedent

Court of Cassation upholds conviction of woman who fed stray animals! Lawyer: Could set precedent

08.11.2026 14:00

A woman who fed stray animals with leftover food at home was tried for the offense of negligent injury after a child in the area was injured in a dog attack. In the case in which the court of first instance acquitted her, the appellate court issued a conviction, and the Court of Cassation upheld the decision. Lawyer Zeynep Sevim said that the decision could set a precedent and might deter citizens from feeding animals.

Lawyer Zeynep Sevim stated that the decision by the Court of Cassation regarding a woman who feeds street animals may be of precedent value, saying, “After the decision, it may be normal for citizens to hesitate to feed street animals.”

THE FIRST INSTANCE ACQUITTED, THE COURT OF CASSATION UPHELD THE CONVICTION

Zeynep Sevim, saying that the Court of Cassation’s decision regarding a woman who feeds street animals is of a nature that may lead to debate, said, “Recently, a controversial decision of a nature that may cause citizens to hesitate to feed street animals was upheld by the Court of Cassation. In the incident, a public lawsuit was filed against a woman who fed street animals with leftover food from her home, on the charge of negligent injury after a child in the area was injured in a way that could be remedied by simple medical intervention as a result of an attack by street dogs. The first-instance court, stating that it was established that the woman fed the animals but that this alone would not create an obligation of ownership or supervision over the animals, issued an acquittal. The appellate court, however, accepted that the defendant created an ecological environment by feeding dogs in the area and that, even if the dogs that carried out the attack were not directly fed by the defendant, she should be held responsible for the damage arising from this environment, and rendered a conviction. The Court of Cassation also upheld the decision. However, this decision gives rise to serious debates with respect to the fundamental principles of criminal law,” she said.

“FEEDING AN ANIMAL AND THE DUTY OF SUPERVISION ARE NOT THE SAME”

Sevim, saying that holding a person responsible merely because she fed an animal means expanding the limits of criminal responsibility, said, “First of all, feeding an animal and assuming a legal obligation of supervision and control over that animal are not the same thing. Holding a person responsible for the acts of other animals with which she has no concrete connection, based merely on the fact that she fed animals, expands the limits of criminal responsibility. At this point, the principles of culpability, causal link, and in dubio pro reo gain importance. While it could not even be established that the dogs that carried out the attack were fed by the defendant, it is legally problematic to render a conviction solely on the ground that she fed animals in the area. This approach may lead to criminal responsibility being based on assumptions rather than on a concrete act and fault. The social impact of the decision should also not be ignored. The concern that people who feed animals may be held criminally responsible for attacks that may occur in the future because of this behavior may negatively affect voluntary assistance to street animals,” she stated.

“ANIMAL FEEDERS MAY HESITATE”

Sevim, saying that it may be normal for citizens to hesitate to feed animals after this decision, said, “Of course, public safety and especially the protection of children are essential. However, this purpose does not justify abandoning the fundamental safeguards of criminal law. A well-intentioned act cannot be made the basis for criminal responsibility without establishing a concrete breach of legal obligation and fault. It should not be forgotten that criminal law is not a law that must always find someone responsible when an undesirable result occurs. Responsibility must be determined by concrete evidence, not assumptions. It may be a normal situation for citizens who voluntarily feed animals to now hesitate because of this,” she said.

In order to provide you with a better service, we position cookies on our site. Your personal data is collected and processed within the scope of KVKK and GDPR. For detailed information, you can review our Data Policy / Disclosure Text. By using our site, you agree to our use of cookies.', '