21.11.2026 12:01
The Court of Cassation has issued a decision that closely concerns homeowners and tenants. The making of a new contract in 2018 with a person who had been a tenant in the same shop since 2005 created a debate over rent increase. The Court of Cassation stated that it cannot look only at the date of the new contract, and that the date the tenant first entered the shop must also be taken into account. The decision revealed that older contracts may also be important in re-determining the rent amount.
In a rent determination lawsuit concerning a business premises in Istanbul used by the same tenant since 2005, the Court of Cassation overturned the local court's decision that was based solely on the date of the latest contract. With the ruling, the start date of the lease relationship will also be taken into account.
SAME TENANT SINCE 2005
The business premises at issue in the decision of the 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation dated March 3, 2026, with case number 2025/3450 and decision number 2026/1141, was leased in Istanbul in 2005. The parties signed a new lease contract in 2018 for the business premises that the same tenant continued to use.
REQUEST FOR 39,000 LIRAS FOR A RENT OF 22,000 LIRAS
In 2021, the tenant's monthly rent was at the level of 22,000 liras. The landlord, arguing that the rent remained low compared with similar business premises in the area, filed a lawsuit seeking to increase the amount to 39,000 liras. The main dispute in the case was which date would be taken as the basis, since five years had not passed since the contract signed in 2018.
LOCAL COURT AND COURT OF APPEALS SAID "FIVE YEARS HAVE NOT PASSED"
The civil court of peace hearing the case ruled that the rent could not be redetermined according to equity, stating that five years had not passed since the 2018 contract. The court held that only the increase clause in the contract could be applied. The 35th Civil Chamber of the Istanbul Regional Court of Appeals, which evaluated the landlord's appeal, also found the local court's decision appropriate and rejected the application.
COURT OF CASSATION OVERTURNED THE DECISION
The 3rd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, examining the file, overturned the decision. Drawing attention to the fact that the tenant had used the property since 2005, the Chamber stated that the 2018 contract might have been aimed at putting the existing relationship in writing rather than establishing a new lease relationship. The decision emphasized that a conclusion could not be reached by looking only at the date of the latest contract. It underlined that the start date of the lease relationship and whether the amount determined in 2018 was in line with the market conditions of that period should be evaluated together.
THE EXPERT WILL REVIEW AGAIN
Following the reversal decision, an additional report will be obtained from the expert for the file. According to the report, two different outcomes may emerge:
- If the amount determined in 2018 is found to be in line with the market rate of that period, the increase clause in the contract and the legal index increase will be taken as the basis for the requested period.
- If it is determined that the amount was below the market rate and that the contract was made to continue the existing relationship, the rent may be determined according to equity by taking into account the initial lease start in 2005.
The reversal decision does not mean that the rent will be directly increased to 39,000 liras. The final amount will be determined based on the expert examination and legal conditions.
THE FIVE-YEAR PERIOD REMAINS IN EFFECT
The five-year period in the law, however, remains in force. According to legal experts, the decision prevents this period from being artificially reset by renewing the contract. If the amount specified in the new contract is in line with the market rate on the date of signature, the five-year period starts from the date of the new contract. In this case, only an increase at the index rate can be requested before the period expires.
WHICH DOCUMENTS ARE IMPORTANT?
In similar cases, old contracts showing the initial start of the lease relationship and bank receipts for rent payments are important for landlords. For tenants, comparable listings showing that the amount at the time the new contract was signed was in line with the market, and expert reports if any, can be decisive.