16.11.2026 13:42
The 18-year prison sentence given to Ali İhsan Kılıç, who shot and killed his neighbor Yahya Köşek—with whom he had a feud in 2022 in İzmir's Bayraklı district over feeding street dogs and land issues—as well as Yahya Köşek's wife Meryem Köşek and their daughter Funda Güçlü, for the murder of Yahya Köşek was upheld by the Court of Cassation. The defendant had been sentenced to aggravated life imprisonment separately for the murders of the two women.
The 18-year prison sentence given to Ali İhsan Kılıç (69), who shot and killed his neighbor Yahya Köşek (61), Köşek's wife Meryem Köşek (57), and their daughter Funda Güçlü (37) in the Bayraklı district of IZMIR, in the retrial held at the court of appeal due to his act against Yahya Köşek, was upheld by the Court of Cassation. The sentence given to the defendant, who had previously received a 16-year prison sentence for killing Yahya Köşek with an 'unjust provocation' reduction, has now been increased.
FEUD OVER A STRAY DOG AND A PLOT OF LAND
The incident occurred on June 10, 2022, on 7171/1 Street in the Orgeneral Nafiz Gürman Neighborhood. An argument broke out between Ali İhsan Kılıç and Yahya Köşek, with whom he was at odds over feeding a stray dog and land issues. As the argument escalated, Kılıç fired a handgun at Yahya Köşek, his wife Meryem Köşek, and their daughter Funda Güçlü, a mother of two. The three injured people taken to hospital by ambulance could not be saved. Ali İhsan Kılıç and his brother Mehmet Kılıç, who were taken into custody, were arrested.
In the indictment prepared after the investigation, life imprisonment was sought three times separately for Ali İhsan Kılıç for 'intentional killing' and for his brother Mehmet Kılıç for 'participation in intentional killing'. The defendants were also requested to be sentenced to up to two years in prison each for 'possessing an unlicensed weapon'. In addition, up to two years in prison was sought for Ali İhsan Kılıç, who threatened the Köşek couple's other daughter Filiz Topaloğlu with a weapon, and up to five years for his brother Mehmet Kılıç, who beat and injured her. The indictment was accepted by the İzmir 12th High Criminal Court.
LIFE SENTENCES AT FIRST INSTANCE
The case filed against Filiz Topaloğlu at the İzmir 9th Criminal Court of First Instance for 'intentional injury' to Mehmet Kılıç was merged with the existing case file. In the case heard at the İzmir 12th High Criminal Court, the panel sentenced Ali İhsan Kılıç to life imprisonment for 'intentional killing' of Yahya Köşek, and to aggravated life imprisonment separately for 'intentional killing of a woman' of Meryem Köşek and Funda Güçlü. Ali İhsan Kılıç was also sentenced to 4 years for armed threat against Filiz Topaloğlu and 2.5 years for 'opposing Law No. 6136 on Firearms, Knives and Other Tools'.
Defendant Mehmet Kılıç was sentenced to 15 years separately for 'aiding intentional killing of a woman' of Meryem Köşek and Funda Güçlü, and to 1 year and 3 months for 'armed intentional injury' of Filiz Topaloğlu. Kılıç was acquitted of the charge of participation in the killing of Yahya Köşek. The panel did not apply any reduction to either defendant. It ruled for the acquittal of complainant-defendant Filiz Topaloğlu.
'UNJUST PROVOCATION' REDUCTION FROM THE COURT OF APPEAL
The prosecutor objected to the acquittal of defendant Mehmet Kılıç and took the ruling to the Court of Appeal. In the case heard in February 2024 at the İzmir Regional Court of Justice 24th Criminal Chamber, the presiding judge stated that while the sentence given by the first-instance court for Mehmet Kılıç remained unchanged, the life sentence given to Ali İhsan Kılıç for the killing of Yahya Köşek was reduced to 16 years after applying an 'unjust provocation' reduction. He stated that the other sentences given to Ali İhsan Kılıç were the same as those of the first-instance court.
After the appeal, following objections by the lawyers, the file was taken to the Court of Cassation. The Court of Cassation overturned the acquittal of Mehmet Kılıç for Yahya Köşek and sought his punishment. However, defendant Mehmet Kılıç died while the case was ongoing. The 1st Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation underlined that the defendants' diabetes and the resulting tendency to become easily angered had no effect on their criminal liability, and that no concrete medical evidence was submitted showing that their mental health was not sound.
COURT OF CASSATION SAID 'INSUFFICIENT SENTENCE'
The Court of Cassation overturned the judgment against defendant Ali İhsan Kılıç, who had received a 16-year prison sentence for 'intentional killing' of Yahya Köşek. The ruling stated that the defendant was given an insufficient sentence and that this was found to be unlawful. The Court of Cassation also emphasized that the acquittal of defendant Mehmet Kılıç for participation in the killing of Yahya Köşek was unlawful. The 1st Criminal Chamber of the Court of Cassation, upholding the other rulings, sent the file back to the İzmir Regional Court of Justice 24th Criminal Chamber for these reasons. The case was heard on October 10, 2025. The panel decided that defendant Ali İhsan Kılıç be sentenced to life imprisonment for 'intentional killing' of Yahya Köşek. Then, accepting that the defendant committed his act under 'unjust provocation', a reduction was made and he was sentenced to 18 years in prison.
COURT OF CASSATION UPHOLDS 18 YEARS
The parties again took this decision of the Court of Appeal to the Court of Cassation. In the cassation review of the decision from the İzmir Regional Court of Justice, it stated that no unlawfulness was found and upheld the decision. Thus, the sentence given to the defendant, who had received 16 years in the initial trial, was increased to 18 years.