Heartbreaking words in the Sinan Ateş case: The helva was roasted in our house

Heartbreaking words in the Sinan Ateş case: The helva was roasted in our house

18.11.2026 18:13

Emotional moments were experienced at the hearing of the file with 9 defendants, which was separated from the main case concerning the murder of former Ülkü Ocakları Chairman Sinan Ateş. Sinan Ateş's sister Selma Ateş reacted sharply to the defendant lawyer's statement, "We are fed up with this file now." Describing the family's years-long struggle for justice, Ateş said, "Because that halva was roasted in our house." The court decided to continue the judicial control measures of the defendants and adjourned the hearing to April 2.

In the case where 9 defendants whose file was separated from the main case regarding the murder of former President of the Ülkü Ocakları Education and Culture Foundation Sinan Ateş are being tried, it was decided to continue the judicial control measures, and the hearing was postponed to April 2.

HIS FAMILY WAS PRESENT IN COURT

In Ankara, the trial of 9 defendants continued at the Ankara 32nd Heavy Penal Court in the file separated from the main case regarding the murder of former President of the Ülkü Ocakları Education and Culture Foundation Sinan Ateş in an armed attack on December 30, 2022. Sinan Ateş's wife Ayşe Ateş, his mother Saniye Ateş, his older sister Selma Ateş, defendant not in detention Gürsel Horat, and the parties' lawyers attended the hearing.

“WE ARE FED UP WITH THIS CASE FILE NOW”

Defendant not in detention Gürsel Horat, who was given the floor at the hearing, said that he repeated his previous defense. Horat's lawyer, however, said, “My client has been victimized where he lives because of this case. His work situation has also become difficult. He is about to transfer his cage. We are fed up with this case file now. We are tired of constant requests for new things. We do not want a new report or another examination.” The lawyer requested his client's acquittal and the removal of the judicial control measure against him.

“THE HALVA WAS ROASTED IN OUR HOUSE”

Sinan Ateş's older sister Selma Ateş, reacting to the defendant's lawyer's words, said, “They say they are bored here; we are not bored. Do you know why we are not bored? Because that halva was roasted in our house. My two children were in primary school when their uncle was murdered. Today they are in high school. Those who were tiny children that day are in the courtroom today. Look at these children. They were in primary school when their uncle was murdered. Sinan Ateş's children were also tiny children. None of them got bored when they cried for their father. My mother is over 70 years old. We travel for kilometers. We are not bored. Because that halva was roasted in our house. We are fighting so that justice is served. How could we get bored of this?” she said.

OBJECTION TO THE EXPERT REPORT 

Aziz Bingöl, lawyer of defendant not in detention Mustafa Ensar Aykal, objected to the expert report, stating that they could not access all of the telephone data. Bingöl argued that the expert who prepared the report had also taken part in the investigation phase and said, “We argue that it is unlawful for a person who took part in the investigation phase to later prepare a report as an expert in the same file. Moreover, the expert report contains estimates instead of concrete findings.” Bingöl requested that the expert be heard at the hearing and that the phones belonging to the other defendants also be examined. Şeyda Şahin, lawyer for the Ateş family, also asked for an explanation of which data were taken as basis in preparing the expert report and for all data from Apple to be made available for the parties' examination. She also requested the arrest of the defendants who violated their judicial control obligations, and if the court held a contrary opinion, the aggravation of the measures. After the statements, the court panel announced its interim decision, deciding to continue the existing judicial control measures for the defendants and reject the other requests, and postponed the hearing to April 2.

In order to provide you with a better service, we position cookies on our site. Your personal data is collected and processed within the scope of KVKK and GDPR. For detailed information, you can review our Data Policy / Disclosure Text. By using our site, you agree to our use of cookies.', '