21.11.2026 10:12
The 9th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation unanimously overturned the Labor Court's decision ordering the payment of severance and notice pay to the worker whose employment contract was terminated due to absenteeism. In the decision, it was emphasized that in a justified termination due to absenteeism, the employer is not obliged to ask the worker for an excuse. The worker, who had 19 years of service, did not go to work for 10 days when his second request for unpaid leave was rejected.
In a ruling closely concerning private-sector employees, the Court of Cassation reminded that an employee who is not considered to be on leave by the employer and does not come to work will be deemed absent. The chamber found erroneous the local court's decision ordering compensation to be paid to the employee.
SECOND LEAVE REQUEST REJECTED
An employee who had worked at the same workplace for 19 years took 90 days of unpaid leave of absence. When the employee requested unpaid leave of absence a second time upon returning, workplace management notified the employee both orally and in writing that leave would not be granted and that the employee must start work on the specified date.
10-DAY ABSENCE RECORD DRAWN UP
Nevertheless, an absence record was drawn up for the employee, who did not go to work, for 10 days. Exercising its right of justified termination, the employer terminated the employee's employment contract without compensation on the grounds of absence.
EMPLOYEE FILED A LAWSUIT FOR COMPENSATION
The employee applied to the Labour Court and requested the collection from the defendant of severance pay, notice pay, annual paid leave, overtime pay, national holiday and public holiday pay, weekly rest day pay, travel and meal allowances, and minimum living allowance receivables.
The defendant employer, on the other hand, pointed out that the plaintiff did not come to work for 10 days after returning from unpaid leave. Arguing that the lawsuit was unfounded, the employer requested that the case be dismissed.
LOCAL COURT SAID "THE EMPLOYEE WAS NOT ASKED FOR AN EXCUSE"
The Labour Court ruled in favor of severance and notice pay on the ground that the employee was not asked whether the employee had an excuse for the absence. The court rejected the claims for minimum living allowance, national holiday and public holiday pay, and travel and meal receivables, and decided to partially accept the case.
The Regional Court of Justice (BAM) rejected on the merits the application of the defendant employer's lawyer, who appealed the decision. Upon the defendant's appeal, the case file was sent to the Court of Cassation.
"THE EMPLOYEE CANNOT TAKE LEAVE ON THEIR OWN INITIATIVE"
The 9th Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation, which examined the case file, stated that an employee to whom the employer has granted paid or unpaid leave cannot be expected to go to the workplace during the leave period, and in this case there can be no question of absence. The decision emphasized that determining the time of annual paid leave falls within the employer's right of management and underlined that the employee cannot take leave on their own initiative. It was recalled that an employee's failure to come to the workplace on the grounds that the employee is using annual paid leave constitutes absence unless the employer considers the employee to be on leave.
"THERE IS NO OBLIGATION TO ASK FOR AN EXCUSE"
The decision, which stated that it was established by the case file that the employee was absent, included the following statements:
"Severance and notice pay were awarded on the ground that the employer terminated the employment contract without asking the employee whether the employee had an excuse for the absence. However, the employer has no obligation to ask whether the employee has an excuse before terminating the employment contract based on the reason for the absence. Moreover, the plaintiff employee's petition containing the request 'for the employment contract to be terminated with compensation' also shows that the employee had no communicable excuse. As a result of these explanations, since the plaintiff, whose employment contract was terminated by the employer for justified cause, cannot be entitled to severance and notice pay, the written acceptance of these claims instead of their rejection was erroneous and required reversal. It was unanimously decided to set aside the decision of the Regional Court of Justice concerning the rejection on the merits of the appeal against the Labour Court decision under appeal, and to reverse the decision of the court of first instance."