19.11.2026 18:02
In the indictment prepared in the investigation into Bolu Municipality's 21 mushroom cultivation tents, million-lira money transfers between companies and payments made to the accounts of the suspects' relatives drew attention. The repurchase of the same tents in 2023 for 34 million 20 thousand TL and the 23.9 million TL difference identified in the expert report were included in the case file.
In Bolu, the indictment prepared in the investigation conducted over Köroğlu Cooperative, Boltartek and 21 cultivated mushroom growing tents revealed striking money transfers and tender procedures. In the process that began with the installation of 21 mushroom tents in 2021, money movements worth millions of liras were detected between companies and the accounts of various individuals. The payment of 34 million 20 thousand liras made for the repurchase of the same tents in 2023 became one of the most important topics of the investigation.
MONEY TRAFFIC IN THE INVESTIGATION EXAMINED ONE BY ONE
In the expert examination of bank movements, money transfers in 2021 from Köroğlu Cooperative to Vizyon Bolu, from there to Aktif Elektrik, and then to the accounts of various individuals were scrutinized.
In the indictment, it was stated that a total of 870 thousand 350 TL was sent by Uğur Şirin to Bahadır Acar, his father İsmail Acar and his wife Hülya Acar. In the same examination, it was recorded that 55 thousand 502 liras 40 kuruş was transferred to Cevat Çatladı's mother Nezahat Çatladı, and 174 thousand TL to Elif Esra Soykan, a partner and officer of Vizyon Bolu company.
IN 2021, A CONTRACT WAS MADE FOR 15 TENTS, THE NUMBER WAS INCREASED TO 21
According to the indictment, a contract regarding the purchase and installation of cultivated mushroom growing tents was signed between Köroğlu Cooperative and Vizyon Bolu Proje Mühendislik İnşaat Sanayi ve Ticaret Limited Şirketi on April 6, 2021.
The contract bore the signatures of Köroğlu Cooperative Board Chairman Cevat Çatladı, Yalçın Soykan on behalf of Vizyon Bolu, and Bahadır Acar, who was stated to have no official duty or authority in the cooperative at that date.
In the first contract, a price of 1 million 207 thousand 500 TL + VAT was determined for the supply of 15 mushroom growing tent systems and equipment. Later, 6 more tents were added to the contract and the total number rose to 21.
In the invoice issued by Vizyon Bolu on July 8, 2021, a price of 1 million 690 thousand 500 TL excluding VAT and 1 million 994 thousand 790 TL including VAT was shown for 21 tents and equipment.
According to MASAK data, Köroğlu Cooperative sent a total of 1 million 962 thousand 96 liras 43 kuruş to Vizyon Bolu in 2021. The total amount transferred from Vizyon Bolu to Aktif Elektrik was 1 million 744 thousand 200 TL.
MONEY FROM AKTİF ELEKTRİK TO UĞUR ŞİRİN, AND FROM THERE, TOO.
According to the bank movements in the indictment, a total of 700 thousand TL was sent by Aktif Elektrik to Erkan Ecevit with the description 'tent payment.' A total of 1 million 290 thousand 725 liras 56 kuruş was transferred from Aktif Elektrik to company officer Uğur Şirin on different dates in 2021.
The transfers made from Uğur Şirin's account were also examined under a separate heading in the indictment. Accordingly, a total of 870 thousand 350 TL was sent to Bahadır Acar, his father İsmail Acar and his wife Hülya Acar. 55 thousand 502 liras 40 kuruş was transferred to the account of Cevat Çatladı's mother Nezahat Çatladı, and 174 thousand TL to the account of Elif Esra Soykan, a partner and officer of Vizyon Bolu company.
One of the striking examples regarding the money traffic was the transaction dated April 7, 2021. On April 6, 375 thousand TL was sent from Köroğlu Cooperative to Vizyon Bolu. On the same day, 184 thousand TL was transferred from Vizyon Bolu to Aktif Elektrik, and the next day, 168 thousand TL. It was stated that the 104 thousand 200 TL sent from Aktif Elektrik to Uğur Şirin on April 7 was transferred by Şirin to Bahadır Acar on the same day.
"UĞUR ŞİRİN DETERMINED THE PRICE"
The supplementary statement given to the prosecutor's office by Yalçın Soykan, an official of Vizyon Bolu and one of the parties to the 2021 contract, also held an important place in the indictment.
Soykan claimed that Bahadır Acar and Uğur Şirin asked him to submit a bid for the cooperative's tent purchase, and that Uğur Şirin determined the bid price. Soykan, who explained that he submitted a bid to the cooperative based on the price told to him, said that after the work remained with his company, he knew that Uğur Şirin would essentially carry out the tents.
Stating that for this reason he sent the money coming into the company account to Aktif Elektrik, Soykan argued that he did not obtain any benefit from the transactions in question and that he carried out the process under the direction of Bahadır Acar and Uğur Şirin.
Evaluating the payment chain in which Vizyon Bolu and Aktif Elektrik intervened, the prosecutor's office assessed that instead of having the tents made directly by the company that actually produced them, an appearance of a higher-cost transaction was created and the cooperative made excess payments.
DEBT-CLAIM DEFENSE FOR THE MONEY SENT TO THE ACAR FAMILY
In his statement to the prosecutor's office, Bahadır Acar argued that in 2021 he was not an officer or responsible person of the cooperative, that he did not sign as a party to the tent contract made with Vizyon Bolu, and that he did not act as an intermediary in the business relations between the companies.
Acar claimed that the money sent to him, his father and his wife stemmed from a debt-receivable relationship. Stating that blockades were placed on the bank accounts of Boltartek company due to its debts, Acar said that for this reason he sometimes used his father's and wife's accounts. He said that the money movements had a counterpart and did not provide him with personal benefit.
Uğur Şirin, for his part, stated that he was the owner of Aktif Elektrik and that he himself carried out the tent system in 2021. He explained that he had the tents made by a company named Hiyera in Konya, and that the company's officer was Erkan Ecevit.
Şirin argued that the money he sent to Bahadır Acar was related to a receivable-payable relationship arising from trade they had previously conducted together. He stated that the money sent to Nezahat Çatladı was related to fertilizer purchase and that there was a producer's receipt for this transaction. He said that the payments made to İsmail Acar might be connected to vehicle trading.
IN 2023, 34 MILLION 20 THOUSAND TL WAS PAID FOR THE SAME 21 TENTS
In the second part of the indictment, the tender process regarding the purchase by Boltartek in 2023 of the 21 mushroom tents established by Köroğlu Cooperative in 2021 was described.
In the tender held by Boltartek in 2023 with registration number 2023/887071, titled "21 Units Cultivated Mushroom Growing Tent System Goods Purchase Work of the Quality Specified in the Technical Specification," the approximate cost was calculated as 32 million 500 thousand TL.
Although 5 companies downloaded the tender document, only Köroğlu Cooperative submitted a bid. The tender remained with the cooperative for a price of 28 million 350 thousand TL.
The amount paid including VAT was 34 million 20 thousand TL.
One of the points highlighted in the indictment was that the 21 tents purchased in 2023 were not new systems. It was stated that the tents in question were already installed in 2021. It was also recorded that an examination of Google Earth images by the prosecutor's office determined that the tents were present in the relevant area in 2021.
23.9 MILLION TL DIFFERENCE IN THE EXPERT REPORT
In the expert report included in the indictment, the fair market value, including VAT, of the 21 tent systems that had been used for approximately three years as of the tender date of 9 October 2023 was calculated as 10 million 97 thousand 189 lira and 20 kuruş.
It was stated that because Boltartek paid 34 million 20 thousand TL including VAT for the same tents, there was a difference of 23 million 922 thousand 810 lira and 80 kuruş between the two amounts. In the expert report, this amount was considered an excessive and unjustified payment.
In the indictment, the difference in question was also addressed as one of the main headings of the allegations concerning the 2023 tender and the process of performance of the obligation.
MATTERS RESTRICTING COMPETITION WERE IDENTIFIED IN THE TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION
In the expert assessments regarding the technical specification of the 2023 tender, attention was also drawn to matters that could restrict competition.
In the report, criticism was made of the failure to provide quantities for infrastructure and construction works such as concrete pipes, manholes and floor concrete, the direct use of the phrase 'by our cooperative' in Article 2.8.4 of the specification, and the setting of the work duration as 30 calendar days.
In the expert assessment, it was stated that these arrangements constituted a violation of the principles of transparency, competition, equal treatment and reliability and were of a nature that could point to a specific person or company.
THE ACCEPTANCE PROCESSES OF THE TENTS WERE ALSO INCLUDED IN THE INDICTMENT
In the goods procurement acceptance process, there was also the allegation that although the tents were systems that had been used for three years, they were accepted as if they were new tents compliant with the technical specification.
The indictment included assessments that the members of the Inspection and Acceptance Commission did not carry out the necessary supervision and inspection and showed the transactions as if they had been carried out on paper.
CEVAT ÇATLADI: I DO NOT KNOW WHERE THE DIFFERENCE WENT
Cevat Çatladı's statement in the file regarding the cooperative's debts and the payment made in 2023 also drew attention.
Çatladı said that the cooperative had a debt of approximately 24 million TL and that after the 34 million 20 thousand TL transaction arranged for 21 tents, a difference of approximately 10 million TL emerged.
Stating that he did not know where this difference went, Çatladı claimed that the money may have been used by Bahadır Acar and Fatih Demiral. He argued that no money personally passed to him.
Bahadır Acar, on the other hand, stated that the amount in question was offset against the cooperative's old debts and did not accept the allegation that he obtained personal benefit. Thus, different narratives emerged among the suspects' statements regarding how the difference that arose in the 2023 transaction was assessed.
5 SUSPECTS DETAINED
In the indictment prepared by the Bolu Chief Public Prosecutor's Office, it was stated that arrest warrants were issued on 1 October 2026 for Bahadır Acar, Cevat Çatladı, Fatih Demiral, Uğur Şirin and Bayram Tarhan, while judicial control measures were applied to the other suspects.
The prosecutor's office evaluated the charge of aggravated embezzlement in the incident concerning the tent procurement process in 2021, and the charges of bid-rigging, rigging the performance of the obligation, aggravated embezzlement and forgery of official documents in the tender process in 2023.
In the indictment, the referral articles and evidence concerning the suspects' actions were listed and a public lawsuit was requested to be filed. The charges and expert determinations in the file will be evaluated during the trial process. The suspects' defenses and the prosecutor's allegations will be considered by the court.
.