Verdict in the case of baby Altay, who was poisoned after pesticide spraying in İzmir! 7.5 years in prison for the company owner

Verdict in the case of baby Altay, who was poisoned after pesticide spraying in İzmir! 7.5 years in prison for the company owner

18.11.2026 18:01

A verdict has been reached in the case of 1-year-old Altay Toprak Kınalı, who died of poisoning after pest control was carried out in an apartment in Konak, İzmir. The court sentenced Bülent Öz, an agricultural engineer and owner of the pest control company, to 7 years and 6 months in prison, and Eyüp G., who assisted with the pest control, to 3 years and 4 months in prison. The defendants were also given a 2-year occupational ban, while the family announced that they will appeal the verdict.

A verdict has been issued in the trial concerning the death of 1-year-old Altay Toprak Kınalı from poisoning after pesticide spraying in an apartment in the Konak district of IZMIR. Defendant Bülent Öz, an agricultural engineer and owner of the cleaning and pesticide company, was sentenced to 7.5 years in prison, while Eyüp G., who assisted with the spraying, was sentenced to 3 years and 4 months. The defendants were also banned from practicing their profession for 2 years.

The incident occurred on November 11, 2024, in the apartment building on 1413 Street in the Kahramanlar Neighborhood of Konak district. The family living on the top floor of the 4-story building had the apartment sprayed. Everyone in the building became ill after the spraying. Upon notification, AFAD Chemical, Biological, Radiological and Nuclear (CBRN) experts, along with fire brigade and medical teams, were dispatched to the address. One-year-old Altay Toprak Kınalı, who lived on the 3rd floor, his mother Raziye Kınalı, his father Recep Kınalı, and university student Gizem Umay and Yurdaer Çelikörs, residents of the building, were taken to hospital. Baby Altay, whose heart stopped five times and was restarted, died three days later. The Kınalı couple, Gizem Umay and Yurdaer Çelikörs were discharged after treatment.

FIRST THEY WERE ARRESTED, THEN RELEASED

Within the scope of the investigation into the incident, 3 people were detained by police teams. Bülent Öz, an agricultural engineer and owner of the cleaning and pesticide company, and Eyüp G., who assisted with the spraying, were arrested by the court they were brought before. E.G., who was determined to have brokered the job, was released under judicial control conditions. After a while, Bülent Öz and Eyüp G. were also released under judicial control. In the investigation conducted by the Izmir Chief Public Prosecutor's Office, AFAD teams' examination determined that the substances used to spray the building were agricultural pesticides that should not be used in residential areas. It was determined that the agricultural pesticides named 'Kingphos' and 'Grainphos', which are harmful to human health, were used in the spraying at the home.

In the report prepared by the 1st Forensic Medicine Specialization Board of the Ministry of Justice Forensic Medicine Institute, it was stated that the baby's death occurred due to poisoning linked to the pesticide applied for insects in the building. The 5th Forensic Medicine Specialization Board of the Ministry of Justice prepared a report stating that Altay Toprak Kınalı died as a result of exposure to chemical phosphine gas. The Izmir Chief Public Prosecutor's Office issued a new detention order for Bülent Öz, the agricultural engineer and owner of the company that carried out the spraying, who had previously been arrested and released under judicial control, and Eyüp G., who assisted with the spraying. The suspects who were taken into custody were arrested at the court they were brought before.

In the indictment, it was stated that in the gas measurement carried out as a result of inspections by AFAD personnel, gas values were at a much higher level than they should be. The defendants were separately sought to be sentenced to life imprisonment for 'premeditated murder by using chemical weapons' and up to 20 years in prison each for 'premeditated injury with a weapon' regarding the poisoning of 5 people. The indictment was accepted by the Izmir 1st High Criminal Court. At the first hearing, one of the defendants, Eyüp G., was released under judicial control conditions.

LIFE IMPRISONMENT WAS SOUGHT, CONSCIOUS NEGLIGENCE RESULTED IN A PRISON SENTENCE

The trial of the defendants continued today with the final hearing held at the Izmir 1st High Criminal Court. Detained defendant Bülent Öz, Altay Toprak Kınalı's family and complainants, and lawyers attended the hearing. Eyüp G., who assisted with the spraying, did not come to the hearing.

The public prosecutor repeated the opinion on the merits he had submitted at the previous hearing. Utku Turan, the lawyer for the Kınalı family, argued that the defendants knew the spraying could have fatal consequences but did not take the necessary safety measures at a sufficient level.

Following Lawyer Utku Turan, who requested that the defendants be punished for 'causing death and injury by possible intent', defendant Bülent Öz, making his defense, claimed that he carried out the spraying by taking the necessary safety measures and requested his acquittal.

After hearing the parties, the court panel sentenced the defendants for 'causing death and injury by conscious negligence'. Defendant Bülent Öz was sentenced to 7.5 years in prison, and Eyüp G. to 3 years and 4 months. The panel also ruled that the defendants be banned from their profession for 2 years.

FAMILY WILL TAKE THE VERDICT TO APPEAL

After the hearing, father Recep Kınalı said they would object to the court's verdict and take the case to the appellate court.

In order to provide you with a better service, we position cookies on our site. Your personal data is collected and processed within the scope of KVKK and GDPR. For detailed information, you can review our Data Policy / Disclosure Text. By using our site, you agree to our use of cookies.', '