The Horror of Kashmir OPED

The Horror of Kashmir OPED

05.02.2022 15:50

'The horror, the horror', the words spoken by Kurtz, Joseph Conrad's leading character in his novel, Heart of Darkness, echo in my ears as 5th February, commemorated by Pakistanis, Kashmiris and freedom loving people across the world, as 'Kashmir Solidarity Day', looms on the calendar once again.

'The horror, the horror', the words spoken by Kurtz, Joseph Conrad's leading character in his novel, Heart of Darkness, echo in my ears as 5th February, commemorated by Pakistanis, Kashmiris and freedom loving people across the world, as 'Kashmir Solidarity Day', looms on the calendar once again.



February 5 reminds us that in this age of human rights, democracy and rule of law, Kashmiris continue to languish under foreign occupation, suffer daily violations of their most basic rights, and for whom the law exists only to harass, intimidate and oppress them rather than protect them. Greater is the irony, indeed the horror, that the violator of their rights is India, the world's self-described biggest democracy. Greater still the horror that the Kashmiris are only demanding which is their right and which was promised to them by the international community, and above all India, – their right of self-determination.



Kashmir Solidarity Day also offers a lesson to India that force and fraud will never be able to defeat the desire for freedom. It has tried all kinds of trickery and used all manner and quantum of force against the people of Kashmir only to see their will unbroken, their belief in the righteousness of their cause unshaken. The Kashmiris want nothing less than India fulfilling the pledges it made to them to grant them their right of self-determination and will settle for nothing less. In this demand the people of Pakistan stand should to shoulder with them.



The Kashmir dispute arose immediately after the partition of British India into Pakistan and present-day India. Under the partition formula Muslim majority areas were to go to Pakistan, geographical contiguity permitting, and Hindu majority areas to India. Kashmir was overwhelmingly Muslim and shared a much longer boundary with Pakistan than India. Unfortunately, the Maharaja of Kashmir, Kashmir's unelected absolute ruler, went against the wishes of his people and decided to accede to India through an "instrument of accession" of patent illegality and dubious provenance. The Kashmiris protested.



To avert the crisis, the UNSC adopted several resolutions, the first dating back to January 1948 stating that the final disposition of Jammu and Kashmir will be determined in line with the will of the people of Kashmir expressed through a free and fair plebiscite conducted under the auspices of the United Nations. Both India and Pakistan agreed to this prescription. Unfortunately, India had no intention of honouring its pledge. Indeed, its pledges were only to buy time. It also knew that a free and fair plebiscite would be a resounding verdict against it.



Ironically, it was India that took the Kashmir dispute to the UNSC on 1st January 1948 claiming that it had brought a 'simple and straight forward' issue before the Council. However, on receiving the response contrary to its wishes, it has been making all kinds of disingenuous attempts to erode the authority and legality of UNSC resolutions.



In 1957, the Indian representative at the UN claimed that 'the commitment about a plebiscite is usually spoken of as though it were the law of the Medes and Persians, but what does it amount to? It amounts to an expression of a wish on the part of the two Governments. The expression of a wish is far less than what may be called as an international obligation'.



To perpetuate its illegal and unjustified occupation of Kashmir, India has been committing massive human rights violations in the territory. Only in the last thirty years, Indian Occupation Forces have martyred over 96,000 Kashmiris. They have raped 11,250 women, arrested and tortured 162,000 persons and destroyed 110,000 properties. In September 2021, 8,652 unidentified mass graves in 89 villages of 6 districts of Indian Illegally Occupied Jammu and Kashmir were discovered with thousands of bullet-riddled bodies, bearing grim testimony to the 'greatness' of the world's biggest democracy and its commitment to democratic norms. Indian oppression in Kashmir is full spectrum, 360 degrees, 24/7, 365 days a year, for the last seventy plus years.



International media and human rights organisations including Amnesty International and International Commission of Jurists have widely highlighted these grave, gross and systematic human rights violations. The UN High Commissioner for Human Rights published two reports, in 2018 and 2019, detailing the appalling human rights situation in the Indian Illegal Occupied Jammu Kashmir.



August 5 2019 opened a new chapter in Indian tricks and fraud perpetrated on the Kashmiris. The Indian BJP-RSS Government unilaterally abrogated articles 370 and 35A of the Indian Constitution. These articles conferred upon Kashmir some protections and were an uncomfortable reminder to India that it was disputed territory. With those articles gone, Kashmir was thrown open to settlement from India thus adding demographic dilution to force and fraud that India had so far employed against the Kashmiris. The logic was with Kashmiris rendered a minority in their own land, their demand for their right of self-determination too would be diluted and should the promised plebiscite ever take place, its result would be pro-India. This is gerrymandering on an epic scale.



Meanwhile egregious human rights violations including communication black-outs, night raids, torture, sexual assault, forced disappearances, cordon and search operations, bulldozing of properties continue without restraint. More than 500 Kashmiris have been martyred by Indian Occupation Forces in fake encounters and extra-judicial operations in the last two years. Thousands more have been arrested and sent to far off prisons in India where their loved ones cannot reach them. Torture remains rampant and collective punishments the rule. Kashmiri leadership in Indian Occupied Kashmir remains incarcerated and the press muzzled. Even dead bodies are not spared the indignities of occupation.



The Kashmir dispute is rich with ironies. Many disputes are intractable because the parties disagree on the solution or there does not appear to be any solution at all. Kashmir is different. Here, the UNSC prescribed a free and fair plebiscite as the solution. All parties accepted the prescription. The solution had the merit of being peaceful and democratic: ask the people of Kashmir and respect the verdict of the majority. And yet the dispute lingers. Another irony is that the world's self-proclaimed biggest democracy is afraid of a democratic exercise such as the plebiscite. And this fear of democracy in action has turned this democracy in theory into one of the world's biggest violators of human rights. Furthermore, this democracy has the dubious distinction of deploying one of the largest occupation armies in history – 900,000 troops, or, 1 Indian soldier for every 10 Kashmiris. And yet, ironically, the Kashmir struggle endures.



It endures because of its inherent righteousness, because the Kashmiris will accept nothing less than what was promised to them and because time has only strengthened the resolve of each succeeding generation of Kashmiris to hold India to its word. It endures because it knows that it has the support of freedom loving people in the world, notably the government and people of Turkey.



Pakistan has and will always stand with its Kashmiri brothers and sisters by extending all political, diplomatic and moral support to their just and legitimate cause.



Conrad's Kurtz was a fictional character uttering, "The horror, the horror," about an imaginary place. In Kashmir, we are witnessing real horror. The situation there is horrible enough, but perhaps the bigger horror is our unwillingness to do something about it. It is, therefore, time to fulfill the promise we made to the Kashmiris so many years ago. In this lies redemption for us and salvation for the Kashmiris.



Muhammad Syrus Sajjad Qazi is Ambassador of Pakistan in Ankara, Turkey.

In order to provide you with a better service, we position cookies on our site. Your personal data is collected and processed within the scope of KVKK and GDPR. For detailed information, you can review our Data Policy / Disclosure Text. By using our site, you agree to our use of cookies.', '