In the Başak Gürkan case, request for aggravated life sentence for father-in-law and acquittal for her husband

In the Başak Gürkan case, request for aggravated life sentence for father-in-law and acquittal for her husband

20.11.2026 17:55

In the trial concerning the murder of Başak Gürkan, who was killed in Ankara by Barış Arslan, whom she was in the process of divorcing, and her father-in-law Kudret Arslan, the prosecutor's opinion was announced. The prosecutor's office requested that Kudret Arslan be sentenced to aggravated life imprisonment for the crime of "deliberate killing of a woman," and that Barış Arslan be acquitted and released. While the complainant's lawyer and the lawyer for the Ministry of Family and Social Services requested that the defendants be punished separately, the trial was adjourned to December 4.

The second hearing of the case concerning the murder of senior engineer Başak Gürkan, who was killed by Barış Arslan, from whom she was in the process of divorcing, and her father-in-law Kudret Arslan, was held at Ankara 12th Heavy Penal Court.

Dozens of women came to the hearing to support Başak Gürkan's family. Despite the crowd, women's organizations and complainants reacted to the hearing not being moved to the large hall. As the defendants, wearing suits, were brought into the courtroom, there was a reaction from the family. Başak Gürkan's mother, Makbule Gürkan, reacted by saying "Murderers."

PROSECUTION'S OPINION ANNOUNCED

The Prosecutor's Office announced its opinion on the merits. In its opinion, the Prosecutor's Office included what happened on the day of the incident and witness statements. The opinion stated that Kudret Arslan spoke toward Başak Gürkan with angry gestures and then attacked her. In witness Ali's statement, it was conveyed that Barış Arslan shouted "Dad, don't do it" while his father stabbed Başak Gürkan.

The opinion also stated that, according to the witness, Kudret Arslan used the phrases "I saved your neighborhood from a piece of filth" and "Honor is cleansed like this" after the incident. It was recorded that Barış Arslan tried to push his father off Başak Gürkan and tried to remove him from the scene. The Prosecutor's Office stated that no credence was given to the defendants' defense that Başak Gürkan insulted them. In the opinion, it was stated that the defendants' statements regarding the insult changed over the stages and contained contradictions, and it was recorded that it was understood that Başak Gürkan did not insult them.

 "HE DID NOT CARE ABOUT THE SCREAMS OF THE 5-YEAR-OLD CHILD"

The Prosecutor's Office also drew attention to the fact that the murder was committed in the presence of a 5-year-old grandchild, stating that the defendant did not consider that the child could be injured or lose her life during the incident and did not care about the child's screams. Although there were findings that the victim acted contrary to the obligation of fidelity in marriage, it was emphasized that this obligation applies between spouses and that she had no obligation of fidelity toward her father-in-law Kudret Arslan.

"UNJUST PROVOCATION AND DISCRETIONARY MITIGATION SHOULD NOT BE APPLIED"

The opinion also stated that, considering the defendant's failure to call an ambulance after the incident, his failure to justify his action on a legitimate ground, and his attitude and behavior at the hearing, discretionary mitigation should not be applied to him.

The Prosecutor's Office requested that Kudret Arslan be sentenced to aggravated life imprisonment for the crime of intentional killing of a woman and that the provisions on unjust provocation and discretionary mitigation not be applied to him. It requested that Barış Arslan be acquitted of the crime of participation in the act of intentional killing.

COMPLAINANT'S LAWYER OBJECTED TO THE ACQUITTAL REQUEST

The complainant's lawyer, stating that they did not agree with the Prosecutor's Office's request for Barış Arslan's acquittal, recorded the following in their defense against the opinion on the merits:

"We do not agree with the opinion regarding the defendant. In his statement before the public prosecutor, defendant Barış said, 'I did not try to stop my father because I was in shock.' Barış's actions caused Başak to be unable to escape from the scene. His attempt to pull away so that his own coat would not be bloodied was assessed in the opinion as if Barış Arslan was trying to push his father Kudret Arslan. However, Barış Arslan acted in unity of thought and action together with his father Kudret Arslan. We request that the defendants be punished separately. "

The lawyer for the Ministry of Family and Social Services also requested that the defendants be punished separately.

DEFENDANT KUDRET ARSLAN'S LAWYER: WHEN WE LOOK AT TURKISH CUSTOMS AND TRADITIONS.

Kudret Arslan's lawyer made the defense: "It is obvious that Kudret Arslan went there to see his grandchild and to discuss some clauses in the protocol with his daughter-in-law. In the camera recordings, he first kissed and hugged his grandchild. As soon as Başak Arslan arrived, she directed severe insults at them. At that moment, when we look at Turkish customs and traditions, Kudret Arslan could not tolerate these insults under the influence of the events concerning his son. We consider that there was severe provocation."

ARSLAN: IF SHE HAD SAID "HELLO DAD, WELCOME," SUCH A THING WOULD NOT HAVE HAPPENED

Barış Arslan, defending against the opinion on the merits, said, "I am very sorry that I could not prevent this painful event despite all my efforts."

Defendant Kudret Arslan also stated, "I was not such a person. I was not a person who would hurt an ant. I loved her like my own daughter. I was not such a person. When I heard the insults, I lost control. I am remorseful, very remorseful. I apologize to the family, to my son, and to my grandchild. I do not know what I did. If she had said 'Hello dad, welcome,' such a thing would not have happened."

THE JUDGMENT HEARING IS ON DECEMBER 4

After the statements, the court announced its interim decision, ruled to continue the detention of defendants Kudret Arslan and Barış Arslan, and postponed the case to December 4 for the judgment hearing.

Before the hearing, women from Batıkent held a press statement in front of the courthouse. In the statement, the following expressions were used: "Women are being killed in the neighborhoods where they live, at the workplaces where they work, in their homes, and in the streets. The places where we build our lives are being turned into death sites for us. It is expected of us to be silent, to be afraid, to get used to it, and to continue our lives as if nothing had happened."  The statement noted the following:

"Neither our anger nor our solidarity will subside. We saw it in the Başak Gürkan case as well: Behind femicides, there are not only men who kill women. There is an order that protects the perpetrators, normalizes impunity, and, instead of preventing violence, leaves women alone in the face of violence. There are policies that do not secure women's right to life, condemn them to poverty, and try to confine them to the home. While this order disregards women's lives, it wants us to wait for justice, to be patient, and to remain silent.

Femicides are not fate! Violence can be prevented, and women's right to life can be protected. We do not accept the sorrow that lasts a few days after every murder, the files left to be forgotten, and the fruitless searches for justice. Because we know that being angry alone is not enough. Our anger becomes a real force only when we come together, stand up for each other, unite our voices, and turn it into an organized struggle.

Women's anger will not be silenced, our solidarity will grow, and our struggle will be organized. Because we are strong when we come together. We will not give up our lives, our rights, or our struggle.

WHAT HAPPENED?

According to the indictment prepared regarding the femicide that occurred in Kardelen Neighborhood of Yenimahalle district in Ankara on September 9, 2025, Başak Gürkan Arslan, who had been living separately for some time and was in the process of divorce, and her husband Barış Arslan came together to discuss the divorce protocol. It was stated that the couple's 5-year-old child was also at home during the incident.

According to the account in the case file, during the meeting, Barış Arslan's father, Kudret Arslan, also came to the house. It was stated that Kudret Arslan first beat Başak Gürkan Arslan, and then, during the incident that ensued, Barış Arslan held his wife and made her vulnerable to his father's attack. In the indictment, it was recorded that Kudret Arslan later attacked Başak Gürkan Arslan repeatedly with the knife in his hand and that the woman died as a result of the knife wounds she sustained.

Başak Gürkan Arslan's sister, Yaprak Gürkan, stated in her statements after the incident that the 5-year-old child who witnessed the murder told what happened. According to Yaprak Gürkan, the child explained how the murder took place by saying, "My father held her, and my grandfather stabbed her."

In order to provide you with a better service, we position cookies on our site. Your personal data is collected and processed within the scope of KVKK and GDPR. For detailed information, you can review our Data Policy / Disclosure Text. By using our site, you agree to our use of cookies.', '