19.11.2026 16:42
The lawyers of Kader Tut, the brother of Gül Tut, known as the singer Güllü, have filed a new criminal complaint against Sultan Nur Ulu and Kervan E., the former fiancé of Tuğyan Ülkem Gülter, regarding her death in Yalova. The lawyers requested the identification of background noises in the audio recordings of the night of the incident, the male voice alleged to be present in the recordings, and the internet conversations at the time of the incident.
In YALOVA, the lawyers of Kader Tut, sister of Gül Tut (52), known as the singer Güllü, have filed a new criminal complaint against Sultan Nur Ulu (25) and Kervan E. regarding Gül Tut's death. They requested the identification of background sounds, a male voice, and internet communications at the time of the incident, which were said to be buried under music and conversations in the audio recordings from the night of the incident.
In the incident that occurred on Vali Akı Street in the Harmanlar Neighborhood of Çınarcık district on September 26, 2025, Gül Tut died after falling from the window of her sixth-floor home. As part of the investigation, her daughter Tuğyan Ülkem Gülter and her friend Sultan Nur Ulu, who was at the home during the incident, were taken into custody. A case was filed against Tuğyan Ülkem Gülter seeking aggravated life imprisonment for the offense of 'premeditated intentional homicide against an ascendant,' while Sultan Nur Ulu was requested to be sentenced to between 2 and 4 years in prison for the offense of 'false testimony.' Tuğyan Ülkem Gülter was sentenced to aggravated life imprisonment in the case in which she was tried for the offense of 'premeditated murder' of her mother. A foreign travel ban was also imposed on Sultan Nur Ulu, whose trial has begun.
'THROW' AND 'JUMP FROM THE WINDOW' IN AUDIO RECORDINGS
Previously in the case, two separate expert reports concerning home security camera footage and audio recordings were prepared by the lawyers of Güllü's son, Tuğberk Yağız Gülter. The first report dated October 28, 2026, and the second report dated November 6, 2026, included the expressions 'Let me go' and 'Let go' attributed to Güllü, 'Throw' attributed to Sultan Nur Ulu, and 'Jump from the window' and 'Run, my mother is gone, run' attributed to Tuğyan Ülkem Gülter. In the second report, the words 'I closed the cameras' and 'I am thinking about how to do it,' attributed to Tuğyan Ülkem Gülter, also drew attention.
DOES THE MALE VOICE BELONG TO THE FORMER FIANCE?
In the expert reports, the conversations stated in the security camera recordings to belong to a male voice were also transcribed. The first report recorded the expressions 'Do you think he is trying to scare?' 'Close the door,' 'There is no honor' and 'Let him throw,' attributed to the male voice, while the second report included the words 'No,' 'I don't want to see' and 'Jump from the window.' However, the reports did not make a definitive determination as to whom the male voice belonged. In the second expert opinion, it was stated that the audio recordings were important for clarifying the incident, but could not by themselves establish the exact manner in which the incident occurred. The lawyers of Tuğberk Yağız Gülter filed a criminal complaint with the Yalova Chief Public Prosecutor's Office against Kervan E. and Sultan Nur Ulu, on the grounds of participation in the murder, alleging that the male voice said to be present in the recordings could belong to Tuğyan Ülkem Gülter's former fiancé, Kervan E.
WAS THERE A THIRD PERSON IN THE HOUSE?
Hasan Kocabey and Şermin Tankut, lawyers of Güllü's older sister Kader Tut, also submitted an additional statement petition to the Yalova 1st Heavy Penal Court to be sent to the relevant criminal chamber of the Bursa Regional Court of Justice. The petition requested an investigation into whether a third person was present in the house during the incident. It requested the determination of whether voice or video calls were made with other people via the phones used in the house, and the identification of the people participating in the calls, the phones, devices, and application accounts. It also requested the examination of narrowed base station records taking the incident times into account, comparison of the phones' location and communication data, and technical examination of digital materials.
Meanwhile, the necessary correspondence for the new evidence submitted to the case file upon the application by Tuğberk Yağız Gülter's lawyers to the Yalova Chief Public Prosecutor's Office was completed. While the evidence was sent to TÜBİTAK for technical examination, Gül Tut's sister Kader Tut's lawyers filed a new criminal complaint with the Yalova Chief Public Prosecutor's Office against Sultan Nur Ulu and Kervan E. In the petition, which requested a new and detailed examination of the audio recordings from the night of the incident, it was alleged that there were conversations not included in or evaluated differently in previous audio analyses, and it was requested that sounds remaining under music and ambient noise be separated through technical methods.
The petition noted that the claims that the recordings contain a male voice or more than one male speaker have not yet been verified, and requested determination of whether the sounds are human speech, how many different speakers they belong to, and the source of the sounds. In this context, it requested separate expert reports from 2 forensic science experts in addition to the Ankara Gendarmerie Criminal Laboratory.
The criminal complaint also requested an investigation into internet use between 01:25:55 and 01:26:33 on September 26, 2025. It requested identification of voice or video calls that may have been made via WhatsApp, FaceTime, and similar applications, and comparison of data on the devices used by Gül Tut, Tuğyan Ülkem Gülter, and Sultan Nur Ulu. The petition also requested that deletion-related correspondence between Tuğyan Ülkem Gülter and Kervan E. be examined together with what came before and after it, and that its connection with the conversations on the night of the incident be investigated.
In the criminal complaint petition, attention was also drawn to the differences between the analyses made on the audio recordings from the night of the incident. The petition stated that the phrase 'Jump from the window' at minute 04:57 of the recording was attributed to a male voice in one expert opinion, while in the analysis stated to be by Mustafa Arapoğlu, the same phrase at minute 04:56 was assessed as belonging to Tuğyan. It was stated that there were also different assessments regarding to whom the phrase 'Okay, see you' belonged, and a comparative examination of the recordings in their original forms was requested.
THE MESSAGE 'YOU NEED TO DELETE THOSE'
The petition also requested an investigation into the message dated November 29, 2025, between Tuğyan Ülkem Gülter and Kervan E., which read 'Here, you need to delete those, only that part.' It requested examination of the correspondence before and after the message to determine which contents were requested to be deleted and whether they were connected with the conversations on the night of the incident. The petition also emphasized that the inability to find the records cannot by itself be considered intentional deletion.
It requested an investigation into whether the expressions 'I want him to see it,' 'Why did you close the door?' and 'Throw' attributed to Sultan Nur Ulu in the new audio analyses were actually said, and determination of the context in which these expressions were used, their addressees, and which stage of the incident they corresponded to. It requested that Sultan's knowledge before the incident, her behavior during the incident, and her communications with other people be evaluated together.
AI INTERFERENCE SHOULD ALSO BE INVESTIGATED
The petition also requested an explanation of operations performed on the audio recordings, such as filtering, cutting, merging, and changing speed and pitch. It requested a technical examination of whether AI-based audio processing methods were used and whether these operations created speech-like sounds that were not present in the source recording.
In the petition, it was requested that an investigation be conducted into Sultan Nur Ulu and Kervan E., as well as other persons whose identities will be determined as a result of the examinations to be carried out, within the scope of joint perpetration, incitement, or aiding and abetting the crime of 'premeditated intentional killing'. The lawyers also requested that, if there is sufficient suspicion and grounds for arrest, the suspects be referred to the judge with a request for arrest.
.