20.11.2026 18:41
A verdict has been reached in the Kırçuval Hotel case, which collapsed in Malatya during the February 6 earthquakes and became a grave for 21 people, including 6 volleyball players and 4 amputee athletes. Of the 11 defendants, 8 received prison sentences ranging from 8 years 4 months to 14 years 2 months, and 3 defendants were acquitted. The court rejected the requests for arrest and imposed judicial control; the mother who lost her son reacted by saying 'They will not serve prison time.'
In the case regarding the collapse of the Kırçuval Hotel, where 21 people lost their lives in Malatya during the February 6 earthquakes centered in KAHRAMANMARAŞ, 8 of the 11 defendants tried without detention were sentenced to prison terms ranging from 8 years 4 months to 14 years 2 months.
HOTEL COLLAPSED IN FIRST EARTHQUAKE
The 7-story Kırçuval Hotel in Dabakhane Neighborhood collapsed in the first earthquake on February 6, 2023. Twenty-one people, including 6 volleyball players and 4 amputee athletes, lost their lives in the rubble, and 4 people were rescued by teams. Within the scope of the investigation into the hotel's collapse, its owner Zafer Kırçuval was arrested and released 3 months later upon objection. Following the prosecutor's investigation, an indictment was prepared against 11 people, including former Battalgazi Deputy Mayor and hotel owner Zafer K.
The indictment sought the trial of Aziz Murat P. and Fırat P., who operated the hotel until 2012; Saffet Kırçuval, who later took over the business; Zafer Kırçuval, who was Battalgazi Deputy Mayor during the earthquake period; technical implementation officers and technical supervisors Serpil Yoloğlu and Fatma Altaş; Mustafa Bingöl, the then Director of Zoning Affairs who approved the building permits; public official Alper Yiğit, who approved the architectural renovation project; public official Mustafa Hakan Büker, who approved the static renovation project; and Hayriye Doğan and İsmail Y., authors of the static renovation project, on the charge of "causing the death and injury of more than one person by conscious negligence," with prison sentences of 2 to 15 years each. The indictment was accepted by the 5th Heavy Penal Court.
Today, the final hearing of the case was held.
At the hearing, along with the parties' lawyers, the defendants not in detention—Aziz Murat Palancı, Fırat Palancı, Saffet Kırçuval, Zafer Kırçuval, and Fatma Altaş—and Zeliha Ağırbaş, who lost her son in the rubble during the earthquake, were present. In the courtroom, Zeliha Ağırbaş stated that she wanted the defendants to receive the heaviest penalty and for justice to be served. After listening to the parties' lawyers and giving the non-detained defendants the right to speak and listening to them, the court panel adjourned the hearing for 20 minutes to decide.
8 DEFENDANTS SENTENCED, 3 ACQUITTED
After the break, the court panel announcing its verdict acquitted Aziz Murat P. and Fırat P., who operated the hotel until 2012, along with İsmail Y. The court panel sentenced Saffet Kırçuval and Zafer Kırçuval to 8 years 4 months each; Fatma Altaş to 12 years 2 months 20 days and 6 years 3 months' ban from profession; Hayriye Doğan to 14 years 2 months and 7 years 7 months' ban from profession; Serpil Yoloğlu to 12 years 2 months 20 days and 6 years 3 months' ban from profession; Mustafa Bingöl to 11 years 1 month 10 days; Mustafa Hakan Büker to 11 years 1 month 10 days; and Alper Yiğit to 11 years 1 month 10 days and 5 years 2 months' ban from profession. It decided to apply judicial control conditions to the defendants.
GRIEVING MOTHER: 'THEY WILL NOT SERVE PRISON TIME'
Speaking to reporters outside the courthouse, Zeliha Ağırbaş said, "This was the final hearing, but unfortunately justice did not surprise us again. Once again the guilty are free and we, the innocent, became the guilty. They will not serve prison time. I could not understand why they were sentenced. If they had no shame, they would have said in court, 'If only your children had not stayed there, they would not have died.' Every day I burn with the pain of my child. Unfortunately, I cannot find anything to say. Because there is no justice in Turkey. We have been fighting for justice for 3 years, but we cannot find it."
Lawyer Çağrı Sarıoğlu, one of the complainants' lawyers, stating that their request was for the defendants to be punished for 'possible intent,' said, "The court panel sentenced some defendants for 'conscious negligence.' The indictment was written on March 29, 2024. So we are talking about a very long trial process. As of today, the final decision of the first court instance in the case has been announced. Of course, we will carry our requests to the appellate court and again make our objections regarding the acquitted defendants. We had requests for the arrest of the defendants along with the verdict. These were also rejected. We will also object to this."