The controversial position before the match was a penalty or not? The commentators agreed on a single opinion.

The beIN Trio team made evaluations after the Beşiktaş-Bodrum FK match played in the 19th week of the Trendyol Süper Lig. Former referees Bahattin Duran, Bülent Yıldırım, and Deniz Çoban claimed that the referee of the match, Mehmet Türkmen, missed 4 penalties, including a controversial position that marked the match.

• Was there a handball by Ali during the corner kick in the 4th minute?

Deniz Çoban: No handball, the ball hit his shoulder. We need to see if the player's arm is carelessly opening up and coming towards the opponent's face. The player's hand is carelessly opening up towards the face. Looking at the Beşiktaş player's reaction, he seemed not to be disturbed at all. He might have thought he hit his own head in the scramble. It would have been more correct if the referee had given a penalty. VAR cannot intervene.

Bahattin Duran: Clear penalty, it shouldn't be a yellow card. He didn't hit his arm, but it was a careless move.

Bülent Yıldırım: The raised arm made contact with the opponent's face. It was a careless intervention and a penalty was needed.

• In the 10th minute, Gökdeniz fell in the penalty area, should there have been a penalty?

Deniz Çoban: Clear penalty. Masuaku had no move for the ball. Gökdeniz saved the ball, his foot got caught on Masuaku and he fell.

Bahattin Duran: The position is a penalty. Gökdeniz took the ball forward, Masuaku carelessly came in and hit Gökdeniz's foot.

Bülent Yıldırım: This position is a clear penalty. Because he came from an awkward angle without a chance to play the ball and made a foot intervention. While Gökdeniz was taking the ball away, Masuaku disrupted him with a careless move.

• In the 28th minute, should there have been a penalty for Immobile's action on Seferi?

Deniz Çoban: No penalty. Immobile hit the ball, that foot will not stay suspended, it will fall down. In the nature of the game of football, according to the laws of physics, Immobile's foot fell down.

Bahattin Duran: There is definitely no violation. Seferi is also pulling his foot back. Seferi goes and hits his foot.

Bülent Yıldırım: No violation.

• In the 52nd minute, was the decision to continue correct in the action of Masuaku on Ali Aytemur, should there have been a penalty?

Bahattin Duran: This position is a penalty. Masuaku carelessly opened his hand.

Bülent Yıldırım: This position is a clear penalty. Careless intervention.

Deniz Çoban: An obvious penalty.

• In the 62nd minute, was the decision to continue correct in the position where Taylan fell, should there have been a penalty?

Deniz Çoban: Clear, obvious, net penalty. VAR clearly and obviously showed the referee the foot stepping. I was sure he would give the penalty. When he didn't, it felt like boiling water was poured over my head. A yellow card and a penalty were needed. The referee is insufficient in two matters. In such delayed interventions, if the intervention is careless and the player has lost the ball, VAR no longer intervenes. It is the referee's discretion. But this is not such a move. Taylan hit the ball, went away, but the action taken was uncontrolled. An uncontrolled action is a penalty as long as the ball is in play.

Bahattin Duran: Very clear penalty. VAR intervention was very correct. I claim that everyone working as VAR in the Süper Lig would have intervened in this. It was a very clear uncontrolled intervention. There should have been a yellow card along with the penalty. No matter how many referees there are in the Süper Lig squad, everyone except this friend Mehmet Türkmen would give a penalty. Mehmet Türkmen, who continued with this in the 62nd minute, gave a foul and a yellow card for the same position outside the penalty area.

Bülent Yıldırım: While the ball is being played in this penalty area and the ball is in play, the goalkeeper got angry with the attacking player in the other penalty area and stepped on his foot this way. VAR would intervene and a penalty decision would be made. The ball was completely irrelevant, I grabbed you by the waist and brought you down, still a penalty. Such an obvious, clear, proven foul. Penalty everywhere, in the sea, on land, in the air.