09.12.2025 09:25
In the 15th week of the Super League, there were controversial moments in the match where Beşiktaş drew 2-2 with Gaziantep FK. Former referees commented on these situations in the Trio program. According to the three referees, the position before Gaziantep's goal was not offside. The penalty expectation from Beşiktaş was considered a 'clear penalty' by all three. Gaziantep's penalty appeal was deemed an undisputed penalty, and the lack of intervention from VAR was criticized.
In the 15th week of the Super League, the match between Beşiktaş and Gaziantep FK ended in a 2-2 draw, marked by controversial decisions. Former referees evaluated the positions one by one on the Trio program.
IS THERE OFFSIDE BEFORE GAZİANTEP FK'S GOAL?
Bülent Yıldırım: "I have to trust technology; my eyes may deceive me. If the system says it's not offside, then it is not."
Deniz Çoban: "According to this image, I think this position is level, and there is no offside when it is level; the decision is correct."
Bahattin Duran: "According to the 3D animation, the position is clear; it is not offside. The camera footage belongs to the VAR system, not the broadcasting organization."
POSITION WHERE BEŞİKTAŞ EXPECTED A PENALTY
Bülent Yıldırım: "From morning to night, from night to morning, it's a foul, a clear penalty. There is sufficient evidence for VAR."
Deniz Çoban: "The player in red is preventing the player in white from hitting the ball. I think it's a penalty. However, it's not a position where VAR can intervene."
Bahattin Duran: "The decision to continue is not correct; I also think it's a clear penalty. VAR cannot intervene."
POSITION WHERE GAZİANTEP FK EXPECTED A PENALTY
Deniz Çoban: "Ersin came in an uncontrolled manner and hit his opponent with his arm. He couldn't play the ball either. While the player was jumping in place, Ersin came and collided with him. Is there a clearer penalty than this? VAR will intervene in this. The referee made a completely wrong decision."
Bülent Yıldırım: "The position is a clear penalty. Ersin came out in a disorganized manner and couldn't play the ball. He hit the opponent hard. A penalty and VAR intervention are necessary."
Bahattin Duran: "Very clear, without dispute. The goalkeeper couldn't play the ball and made a foul on Tayyip Talha in an uncontrolled manner. There should definitely have been a penalty, a yellow card, and VAR intervention."