Haberler      English      العربية      Pусский         Kurdî      Türkçe Delivering News and Insights Around the World Keltis
  En.Haberler.Com - Latest News
SEARCH IN NEWS:
  HOME PAGE 30/06/2022 00:39 
26.05.2022 00:57 News >> Norway's Child Welfare Agency Comes Under Fire

Norway's Child Welfare Agency Comes Under Fire

Welfare service Barnevernet criticized by families, activists, lawyers for its controversial decisions.

Norway's child welfare agency Barnevernet has been the subject of controversy, with its decisions fueling growing concern among families, human rights lawyers and activists.
In some cases that families brought to the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), Norway has been convicted several times in connection with Article 8 of the convention which provides that everyone has the right to respect for their private and family life, human rights lawyer Stephanos Stavros told Anadolu Agency.
"In Norway, it is much easier for the child welfare authorities to take away children from their natural parents and put them in public care than to release them for adoption, to sever any contacts between the children and their natural parents," Stavros added.
The ECHR was particularly critical of the decision to cut the ties between a child and their biological family, he said.
"Norway has been forced to take measures in order to comply with the judgments of the court, and now we are in the process of reviewing whether these measures have been adequate," he added.
Since 2015, the Barnevernet's practices, which have mostly involved taking away children from their families by citing "abuse," have been highly criticized both inside and outside the country.
The lack of relevant evaluations and ignoring cultural differences while deciding on cases of "child removal" are among the main reasons behind the criticisms.
On Sept. 10, 2019, the ECHR ruled that Norway violated Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
Authorities creating conditions leading to adoption
Conditions created by the authorities led to an interruption of the real bonds between natural parents and their children and the adoption of the children because of the limited contact, Stavros said.
"So there were contact visits, for example, two or three times per year, two hours each time, and then the conclusion three years later was that the child didn't have any real bond with their natural parents. But it was precisely the decision of the authorities to limit the child's contact with their natural parents that led to the non-existence of the natural bond," he added.
Touching on the case of the son of Mariya Abdi Ibrahim, a Muslim refugee who came from Somalia at the age of 16 and was forcefully taken by Norwegian authorities in 2010, Stavros said the big problem in this case is that the child of a Muslim mother was taken and given to a family of "Christian religious fundamentalists."
"If there is such a huge difference in the beliefs between the natural mother and the foster family and the child stays with the foster family for quite a while, the child will become estranged from the mother," he said.
He went on to say that if you take this decision, inevitably it becomes immediately clear that the child will become estranged from the mother.
Also, Mariya was clearly struggling with different identities, he said, adding she was trying to find a new identity in Norway. She said she did not want her child to become a Norwegian or a Christian. The authorities' response was that in Europe, you cannot impose your identity on the child.
it is a "brutal response to somebody who's struggling to find their place in Norway," he said, adding from the point of integration, there was a clear failure.
Also, "there were 10 to 15 violations under all these cases still pending before the Committee of Ministers for execution. Norway has given compensation to most of these parents," he said.
'No system is perfect'
Occasionally, there are misunderstandings about the work of Norway's child welfare agency, Kristin Ugstad Steinrem, director at the Norwegian Directorate for Children, Youth and Family Affairs, told Anadolu Agency.
"No system is perfect. There can be mistakes. That's why we always strive to improve our work to ensure that children are raised safely in Norway, said Steinrem.
They welcome the ECHR's review of the Norwegian child welfare system, as the majority of cases brought to the ECHR have concluded against Norway, she added.
"We can strive to do better. Some measures have already been taken to ensure compliance with ECHR decisions. The Norwegian Supreme Court has also decided to hear four new cases," she said. -



        Latest News
R. Kelly Sentenced To 30 Years In US Federal Prison For Sex Trafficking, Sex With Minors 30 minutes ago...
'Kelly relied upon his fame, money and popularity,' say prosecutors.
Dow Gains; S&P 500, Nasdaq Off During Volatile Session -15 minutes ago...
Blue chip Dow adds 82 points to close at 31,029.
Türkiye 'Satisfied With Constructive Approach' By Sweden, Finland -15 minutes ago...
'We will work to ensure that NATO has more unity on terrorism,' says Turkish communications director.
Central Banks' Challenge Is To Control Inflation Without Recession: S&P 0 minutes ago...
High prices, aggressive Fed make it hard for US economy to 'walk out of 2023 unscathed,' says rating agency.
France, Türkiye Committed To NATO's Unity, Strength: French President 15 minutes ago...
Both countries to continue to make efforts to ensure export of Ukrainian grain, says Emmanuel Macron.

 
      Top News
Biden, Erdogan Agree On 'Continued Close Consultations' Between US, Türkiye Biden, Erdogan Agree On 'Continued Close Consultations' Between US, Türkiye
Spain's Annual Inflation Rate Hits 37-Year High Spain's Annual Inflation Rate Hits 37-Year High
Diary Diary
Turkish Soldier Killed In Anti-Terror Operation In Northern Iraq Turkish Soldier Killed In Anti-Terror Operation In Northern Iraq
Türkiye Expects NATO Summit To Reinforce Solidarity, Unity, Cohesion Among Allies Türkiye Expects NATO Summit To Reinforce Solidarity, Unity, Cohesion Among Allies
Census Reveals Half Of Australians Are 1St Or 2Nd-Generation Migrants Census Reveals Half Of Australians Are 1St Or 2Nd-Generation Migrants
75 Irregular Migrants Rescued Off Mugla, Türkiye 75 Irregular Migrants Rescued Off Mugla, Türkiye
UN Alarmed Over Increasing Violence In Palestine, Israel In Recent Months UN Alarmed Over Increasing Violence In Palestine, Israel In Recent Months
10 Die In Toxic Gas Leak In Jordan 10 Die In Toxic Gas Leak In Jordan
Putin Accepts Invitation To G20 Summit In Indonesia Putin Accepts Invitation To G20 Summit In Indonesia