03.11.2025 13:01
In the 11th week of the Super League, the decisions made by referee Ali Yılmaz during the Beşiktaş - Fenerbahçe derby sparked controversy. In the beIN Trio program broadcast on beIN Sports, former referees Deniz Çoban, Bahattin Duran, and Bülent Yıldırım evaluated the incidents in the derby one by one. The trio agreed that two clear penalties in favor of Fenerbahçe were not awarded.
```html
In the 11th week of the Süper Lig, the decisions of referee Ali Yılmaz in the Beşiktaş - Fenerbahçe derby became a topic of discussion. In the beIN Trio program broadcasted on beIN Sports, former referees Deniz Çoban, Bahattin Duran, and Bülent Yıldırım evaluated the positions in the derby.
Was the decision to continue correct in the position where Kerem Aktürkoğlu fell in the 45+1 minute?
Bülent Yıldırım: There is a foul. Clear penalty. The referee is indecisive, looking one way and then the other. The assistant referee stylishly indicates a goal kick. The referee remained indecisive without making any decision and continued. The assistant indicated a goal kick, and the game started with a goal kick. He placed his foot between the ball and the opponent's foot. It should have been a penalty. VAR should have intervened.
"CLEAR PENALTY"
Bahattin Duran: In this position, VAR may not intervene at the UEFA level, but this position is a clear penalty. The referee did not make a decision. The biggest problem is this. Salih came and placed his foot in front of Kerem from behind, obstructing his shot and the quality of the shot. This is a foul and a penalty. The referee team could not decide either. The assistant referee raised a flag, lowered it, indicated a goal kick, and so on...
"OBVIOUS PENALTY"
Deniz Çoban: It is an obvious penalty that cannot be doubted. You cannot come from behind and place your foot in front of the swinging foot. This is a foul.
Was the decision to continue correct in the position where Duran fell in the 90+4 minute?
Bahattin Duran: According to the rule, the action of Beşiktaş player Gökhan against Duran is a push. The consequence of a push in the penalty area is a penalty. The correct decision is a penalty.
PENALTY AND RED CARD
Bülent Yıldırım: A position within the referee's discretion, theoretically. While preparing for the shot, he pushes from behind and disrupts. Penalty and red card.
Deniz Çoban: This is a clear penalty. There is no struggle for the ball. If he awards the penalty, a red card will also be issued.
REFEREE'S REPORT CARD
Bülent Yıldırım: His total match experience is also low. He should continue to work.
Bahattin Duran: Managing a derby is very difficult. He did not manage it well, but it was a significant experience. He was very lucky on that day.
Deniz Çoban: He did not award 2 penalties in favor of Fenerbahçe. The tension is low because Fenerbahçe won. A chance in the score. The players did not escalate the issues either.
```